PROFILES

Punch-Card Love

March/April 2007

Reading time min

Portraits of Fialer and Harvey

MATCH GAME: Fialer and Harvey started the Happy Families Planning Service; part of the flow chart for their dating experiment is shown below. Photos: Stanford Quad

In a world where Match.com, eHarmony and other online dating services are staples of single life, a handful of Stanford alums are pretty sure they did it first.

In 1959, Jim Harvey, ’58, and Phil Fialer, ’60, MS ’64, enrolled in Math 139, Theory and Operation of Computing Machines. The draw: getting to do a project using Stanford’s IBM 650 mainframe computer. The pair chose to try their hand at matchmaking and put together questionnaires for the Happy Families Planning Service. The students were limited to five or 10 minutes on the mainframe, so they initially were able to run the punch cards for only 10 couples. But with the help of some lock-picking skills, Fialer and Harvey returned to the lab late one evening and ran the data for the rest of the questionnaires—a total of 49 couples.

The “dates” met up at a party hosted by Fialer and Harvey at their rented house on Los Trancos Woods Road in Portola Valley. A few of the pairings were unfelicitous: the computer matched a freshman from Wilbur with a divorcee with two children who lived in Los Trancos Woods. None resulted in a long-term match.

A flow chartChart: Courtesy James Harvey

Commercializing the idea never occurred to them. “I wish I could have had the foresight,” says Harvey, whose career was in aerospace engineering. “Maybe I would have been a Google or something.”

A few years later, a similar experiment had a different outcome. Egged on by a friend, Marlyn Anderson, ’65, responded to an ad in the Stanford Daily for another matchmaking experiment. One of her matches was Gordon Keating, MD ’67, a shy, gentle psychiatrist-in-training. The couple married the summer after he finished medical school. They still have the printout that Gordon got from the experimenters.

The details of the match have grown foggy with the passing of years. Neither remembers where their first date occurred (“Was it was a French restaurant, do you remember, Gordon?” Marlyn asks. “I thought it was Italian,” her husband answers) or whether the matchmaking was a sociology or psychology department project. “It’s hard to remember the beginning,” says Marlyn Keating, now director of fiscal services for a school district in Washington. “We’ve evolved and influenced each other and have developed a shared view of the world.”

Trending Stories

  1. 8 Tips for Forgiving Someone Who Hurt You

    Advice & Insights

  2. Bananas Are Berries?

    Culture

  3. Should We Abolish the Electoral College?

    Law/Public Policy/Politics

  4. The Case Against Affirmative Action

    Law/Public Policy/Politics

  5. The Huberman Effect

    Health/Wellness

You May Also Like

© Stanford University. Stanford, California 94305.